The January Effect: Why Good Marriages Fall Apart This Month

Jan 7

Written By Taralee Eddington

I need to tell you something that might surprise you.

The marriages that fall apart in January aren't usually the ones that have been terrible for years.

They're the ones that were "fine" in November.

The ones where both people were still trying.

The ones where, from the outside, everything looked manageable.

And then January hits... and suddenly it all feels impossible.

If that's where you are right now, I want you to know: You're not crazy. And you're not alone.

What December Does To Your Marriage

December is survival mode disguised as celebration.

You're juggling family expectations, financial stress, kids' schedules, and the pressure to make everything "magical."

And somewhere in the middle of all that chaos, the cracks in your marriage get temporarily plastered over.

Not healed. Just... covered.

You're too busy to fight. Too distracted to feel the loneliness. Too exhausted to have the "serious talk" you've been putting off since October.

So you make an unconscious agreement with yourself: Just get through the holidays. We'll deal with this later.

And you do get through them.

But "later" is now here.

The January Reckoning

January is what I call the "emotional hangover" month for marriages.

All the tension you postponed?

All the conversations you avoided?

All the feelings you suppressed so you could smile through Christmas dinner?

They're still there. Waiting for you.

And now that the noise has died down and the house is quiet, you can finally feel the full weight of what's been building.

For some people, it hits like a wave of panic:

"I can't do this for another year."

"How did we get here?"

"Is this really what the rest of my life looks like?"

For others, it's more like resignation:

"I think I'm done."

"I don't even know if I love them anymore."

"Maybe we're just not meant to be together."

Either way, January has a way of forcing clarity—whether you're ready for it or not.

But Here's The Problem With January Clarity

When you're emotionally exhausted, your brain doesn't give you clarity.

It gives you relief fantasies.

Let me explain what I mean.

When you've been in pain for months (or years), your brain starts looking for the fastest exit.

And divorce feels like an exit.

It feels like:

No more walking on eggshells
No more trying and failing
No more pretending everything's fine when it's not
Freedom from this constant, crushing weight

So your brain shows you the highlight reel of what leaving would look like:

Peace. Space. Starting over. Finding someone who actually gets you.

But it doesn't show you the full picture:

Telling your kids
The financial devastation
Splitting holidays
Co-parenting with someone you can barely talk to
Dating again in your 40s, or 50s, or 60s
The guilt that follows you for years

I'm not saying those things should make you stay.

I'm saying your brain, when it's desperate for relief, doesn't give you the full truth.

It gives you the version that feels best in the moment.

And that's a terrible foundation for life-altering decisions.

The Questions Nobody Asks

When couples come to me in January, I ask them questions they weren't expecting:

"When's the last time you felt emotionally safe with your spouse?"

Most people can't remember.

"Have you ever been taught how to repair after a fight?"

Almost no one has.

"Do you know what your marriage is actually starving for?"

Blank stares.

Here's what I've learned after working with many of couples in crisis:

Most marriages don't end because people stop loving each other.

They end because people never learned the foundational skills that make love sustainable.

Nobody taught us:

How to regulate our nervous systems when we're triggered
How to communicate when we're hurt without attacking
How to rebuild trust after it's been broken
How to repair connection when it's been severed
How to identify what our marriage actually needs to survive

We were handed the dream—partnership, family, forever—but never given the blueprint.

So we do our best.

We try harder. We read books. We go to therapy.

And when it still doesn't work, we assume the marriage itself is the problem.

But what if it's not?

What if you've just been trying to fix the wrong thing?

The Real Question

The question isn't: "Should I stay or should I go?"

The real question is: "Am I making this decision from clarity... or from exhaustion?"

Because exhaustion will tell you to quit.

Clarity will tell you what's actually broken and whether it can be fixed.

And those are two completely different answers.

I've worked with couples who were 100% certain their marriage was over.

One foot out the door. Lawyer's number saved in their phone. Separation conversations already started.

And six weeks later, they're texting me: "I can't believe we almost gave up. This feels completely different now."

Not because they worked harder.

Not because they suddenly became different people.

But because they finally understood what was actually happening—and how to fix it.

What January Needs From You

If you're in crisis right now, January doesn't need you to make a decision.

January needs you to get honest.

Honest about:

What's actually happening (not the story, but the facts)
What you've been avoiding
What you don't know how to do
What you're afraid of
What you actually want

And then January needs you to get help.

Not generic advice.

Not another book that tells you to "communicate better."

Not more date nights that feel forced and awkward.

But real, structured support from someone who understands marriage crisis—not just marriage maintenance.

What Happens Next

This week on my podcast, I'm diving deeper into why January is the breaking point for so many marriages—and what actually saves them.

I'll be talking about:

The neuroscience of why your brain pushes you toward escape
Why most marriage advice makes crisis marriages worse
The filter I use to help couples see what's really happening
And what skills you actually need to rebuild (that nobody ever taught you)

The episode drops this Friday (January 9th) and I think it might be exactly what you need to hear right now.

You can subscribe to The FOCUS Podcast with Taralee wherever you listen.

And you can find it here on YouTube, too.

And If You Need More Than A Podcast Episode...

I created a free training specifically for couples (or individuals) in crisis.

It's 15 minutes long.

No fluff. No therapy-speak. Just straight talk about:

Why everything you've tried hasn't worked
What's actually causing the breakdown
The 5 foundations your marriage is missing
And how to know if your marriage can still be saved

[Watch the free training here →]

One Last Thing

Your marriage ending in January doesn't have to be inevitable.

But it will be if you keep doing what you've been doing.

Einstein said it best: "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results."

If you want something different, you have to do something different.

And that starts with getting the right support.

Not someday. Not after one more fight. Not when things get unbearable.

Now.

Because January doesn't have to be the month your marriage ends.

It can be the month you finally understand what it needs to survive.

💛 Taralee

P.S. If you're reading this and thinking "I don't even know if I want to save it anymore"—that's okay. You don't have to know yet. But you deserve to make that decision from a place of clarity, not exhaustion. Watch the training. Listen to the podcast. Give yourself the information you need to decide wisely.

About Taralee Eddington:

Taralee is a Marriage Crisis Coach and founder of Peaceful Heart Journey. She helps couples rebuild emotional safety, trust, and genuine connection—even after betrayal, years of distance, or constant fighting. Through her Marriage Breakthrough Program and the FOCUS Framework, she gives couples the tools and clarity they need to decide their future from a place of strength, not panic.

Connect with Taralee: